Nosh With Josh
  • The Stories
  • Noshes
  • When and Where
  • Articles By Josh
  • About
Your Bubbie Would Follow Me...

Moderation: The No Diet Diet

7/1/2012

10 Comments

 
Tomorrow, I begin training for the New York City Marathon, and as I mentally prepare myself for the road ahead, I find myself focusing a lot on food.  

Then again, why should this day be any different?

Back in 2009, I had my first run at a 26.2 mile journey as I looked to tackle Chicago.  Always in relatively good shape but without the desirable “six-pack abs” body to show for it, I decided this would be the perfect time to seize the opportunity and lose some weight, change my body composition, and take on a figure that would leave me unashamed to go shirtless as much as possible.

Even during the brutal Michigan winters.

During my six-month campaign, however, a combination of ignorance, self-consciousness, and information overload left me ignoring common sense and proper nutrition in favor of weight loss.  Increasing miles and decreasing calories, combined with the low-carb craze was a perfect recipe for shedding away that belly I once possessed and despised. 

When all was said and done, I finished the marathon in a time of 3:16:11, but at the cost of about 30 pounds: more than half of which I couldn’t truly afford to lose. 

This mentality stayed with me for quite some time thereafter.  I had already lost the weight, and feared that if I changed something, anything, that I might revert back into my previous “mediocre” physical state.  Decisions on food consumed my life and altered my daily routine.  Fortunately, with the help of family and friends, I can happily report that I’m right back on track to where I need to be.

This time around, I plan to do things a little differently.  A lot differently.  Completely differently. 

Which is why I’ve recently been pondering my own eating habits.  Since moving to San Francisco, I’ve definitely partaken in more than my fair share of Tartine pastries, Bi-Rite ice cream and Pliny the Elder.  Excited to explore my new city through food, I may have floored it a little too quickly. 

I regret nothing. 

But it did lead me to ask the question: What comprises a “healthy” lifestyle?

One of my closest friends recently took up the Paleo diet, which in short, attempts to mimic the lifestyle of those living during the Paleolithic era.  Tons of lean meats and leafy greens make up the vast majority of his intake, with the occasional handful of nuts and even more scarce nibbles fruit, limited to dark berries.   No dairy, no legumes, no grains.  He, and many others, have expressed the wonders that this change has done for them in terms of both weight and overall well-being. 

While I by no means contest their claims, I do have some qualms with the adoption of such measures.  Personally, I am vehemently anti-diet, and have always been a firm believer that your body knows what it wants.  Cravings are merely signals to alert your body that it requires something – nutrients, vitamins... – and that which you desire is the way in which your personal history remembers how to attain it.  A craving for ice cream may not be as much be a hankering for junk food as it is your body yearning for calcium. 

Diets by their very nature are restrictive, and it is this sort of self-imposed limitation that causes people not only to “relapse,” but also to overindulge when the time comes (and it will) to cave in.  And when the stresses of ensuring you adhere to an arbitrary set of rules and regulations overpowers the joy you may receive from happily indulging in the occasional (re: occasional) sugary delight, what are you really sacrificing? 

People often times underestimate the value of the psychological benefits gained from indulging from time to time.  By no means am I advocating eating an entire pie in the name "emotional stability," but in evaluating the decision to indulge, the negatives (unhealthy, fattening...etc.) generally focus in the forefront.  The mental benefits, however, are often put on the back burner. 

Besides, it is a much more social (and healthier) venture to share a dessert than it is a salad. 

More importantly, we have the ability to condition ourselves to recognize other sources, healthier sources, to achieve that same missing puzzle piece.  By diversifying our food sources with a variety of fruits, vegetables, proteins, fats and carbohydrates, we can discover better ways to reach the desired goal of providing ourselves the nutrients we desire.  As a result, the decision to reach for a bundle of kale to quench that very same calcium deficiency becomes just as turnkey as polishing off a pint of Ben and Jerry’s.

Well, maybe not that easily. 

Yet this diversification comes with a qualification – it has to be real, honest to goodness food.  We genetically modify and manipulate food so that people are able to have something similar to genuine fare, just so that it complies with the latest craze.

Comedian Lewis Black (crudely - NSFW) explains:
With so much uncertainty about what is and is not “good” for us, combined with the dominance of processed provisions in the supermarkets, convenience often takes precedence over health.

But look around – never has there been a time where organically grown fruits and vegetables are so ripe for the picking.  Farmers’ markets abound!  Natural, real food in such a variety of brilliant colors, shapes, sizes, tastes and textures are all so close at hand that it seems almost irresponsible to choose anything else.  It is not difficult to appreciate all that nature has to offer us. 

My consumption habits will almost certainly change, as the demands of pounding pavement for 40 miles a week will take a huge toll on not only my caloric needs, but my nutrient needs as well.  Still, there are still questions to be answered and decisions I have to make:

Will I give up beer and bread? 

You must be joking.

Am I going to skip out on my latte and saffron snicker doodle cookie at Blue Bottle on Saturday mornings?

No chance in hell.

Will I do all of this with a greater degree of restraint?

Absolutely.

For me, it is all about having everything in moderation; junk food included.  Those who propose any sort of diet subscribe to the notion that at any given point, a particular item’s detriment outweighs its benefit.  However, this is merely a short-term snapshot.  Over the long haul, I submit that the wider range of nutrients taken from various sources will improve our overall health by exposing us to a more in-depth spectrum of possible sources for life's essentials, while simultaneously increasing our ability to resist disease and allowing us to enjoy the food we eat that much more.

Economics teaches us not to put all of our eggs in one basket, and that diversification in the market is ideal.  This is my philosophy when it comes to the foods I choose to eat.  There is just so much uncertainty out there that I hesitate to entirely eliminate (or conversely, only consume) a singular set of anything.  For every study that proves that a vegan diet is ideal, there are twenty more just like it showing that a strip of bacon a day keeps the doctor away.  

That’s my kind of doctor!

Our bodies are all so unique and with different needs that I refuse to accept the fact that there is one specific method of dieting that is the end-all be-all solution to consumption.  It just isn't possible.  But by keeping processed items to a minimum, enjoying a blanketed menu of naturally occurring fruits and vegetables, and ultimately enjoying the food we eat, we'll all be just fine.  

Nosh on (in moderation),
Josh
10 Comments
matt thau
7/2/2012 02:16:41 am

Couldn't agree more with you, Josh. The food in today's restaurants and coming out of today's supermarkets is entirely too wonderful to ignore at the expense of a fad diet. "Everything in moderation", as someone wise once said. Good luck with your training, ill be sure to follow along with your blog. Enjoy eating in one of the finest culinary cities in the country

Reply
Josh Leskar link
7/3/2012 03:07:31 am

Matt! Thanks for the awesome comment - I really appreciate it. What are you up to these days?!

Any time you're out here, please pick up the phone and give me a call. I'd love to show you around!

Reply
where to buy garcinia cambogia link
4/11/2014 04:13:48 pm

Great information shared with the users here, its noteworthy one to get a great information for future business purpose.

Reply
where can I buy garcinia cambogia link
4/11/2014 04:14:11 pm

i liked this article published here on this superb platform, it needs to be followed wisely as mentioned for absolute results always

Reply
stores that sell garcinia cambogia link
4/11/2014 04:14:39 pm

My reasearch work has just came to a conclusion after reading this brilliant masterpiece and i am making a wise decision to share it

Reply
Jill Allingham
7/5/2012 07:50:10 am

Josh, Did you know my motto is "Everything in Moderation"? Seriously I just had Vanilla Cherry ice cream at 2:47 this afternoon. Not the entire 1/2 gallon, just 2 1/2 scoops. Now it is 4:46 and I am drinking Joel Gott Chardonnay with mixed nuts. Dinner will be salmon, mixed vegetables, signature salad and more wine of course. Maybe a chocolate or two after dinner. I call that pretty good DIET.

Reply
Brian Yost
7/5/2012 10:08:48 am

If I were living in San Fran with you I would certainly never give up anything and do my best to limit the Tartine visits to once a day. It's all about finding the easiest way to sustain a healthy lifestyle which you figured out a long time ago.

Also, this blog would be crazy boring if you only talked about meat and veggies. Ok, I would still read even if it had only pictures of steak everyday.

Reply
http://www.mypaleodiet.net/ link
9/19/2012 02:05:46 pm

Funny posts. Cool idea by the way :)

Thanks for the entertainment.

Reply
casino online link
6/13/2013 10:56:24 pm

I agree with Jill! Dinner should be a light one like salmon, mixed vegetables, signature salad. Maybe a chocolate or two after dinner.Pretty good DIET before the marathon. Anyway good luck you in you starting.

Reply
Door Frames link
9/7/2014 06:28:54 pm

I have been searching for quite some time for information on this topic and no doubt your website saved my time and I got my desired information. Your post has been very helpful. Thanks.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Writer, educator, and positive peer-pressurer. 

    Categories

    All
    Adhoc
    Airbnb
    Bestia
    Blue Bottle Coffee
    Bouchon Bakery
    B_Patisserie
    Craftsman And Wolves
    Egg Slut
    Flour+Water
    Forage Kitchen
    Four Barrel
    Goodyfoods
    Great Divide Brewing Company
    Handsome Coffee Roasters
    Hapa Ramen
    Ice Cream Bar
    La Petite Sf
    Local: Mission Eatery
    Magnolia
    Marla Bakery
    Monk's Kettle
    Nopalito
    Outerlands
    Outstanding In The Field
    Ragazza
    Rich Table
    Rickybobby
    Ritual Coffee Roasters
    Satellite Republic
    Schmendricks Bagels
    Smitten Ice Cream
    Sqirl
    State Bird Provisions
    The French Laundry
    The Mill
    Trouble Coffee Co.

    Archives

    January 2014
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012

    Tweets by @josh_leskar
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.